How Property Tax Appeals Work

Filing a property tax appeal in Allegheny County might seem intimidating, but the process is designed to be accessible to homeowners. Understanding how it works can help you feel more confident about pursuing an appeal if your assessment appears too high.

The Appeal Process Step by Step

Step 1: Determine If You Have a Case

Before filing, verify that your assessment appears high compared to similar properties. Our free calculator can help you determine this quickly using the current Common Level Ratio.

You generally have a strong case if:

  • Your assessment ratio exceeds 49.3% (the 2026 CLR)
  • Comparable properties in your area have lower assessments
  • Your property has issues that affect its value (damage, etc.)

Step 2: Gather Your Evidence

Strong evidence is key to a successful appeal. You'll need:

  • Comparable sales: 3-5 recent sales of similar properties in your neighborhood
  • Property details:Photos showing your property's condition
  • Assessment notice: Your current assessment from the county
  • Market analysis:Data showing your property's fair market value

Our sample report shows exactly what a complete evidence packet looks like.

Step 3: File Your Appeal

In Allegheny County, you file your appeal with the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (BPAAR). You have two options:

  • Online:Through the county's e-Filing system
  • By mail: Send forms to the BPAAR office

The appeal form requires basic information about your property and the reasons you believe your assessment is incorrect.

Step 4: The Hearing

After filing, you'll receive a hearing date. At the hearing:

  • You'll present your evidence to a board member or hearing officer
  • The county assessor may also present their case
  • You have the opportunity to explain why your assessment should be lowered

You do not need a lawyer for this initial hearing. Most homeowners represent themselves successfully.

Step 5: The Decision

You'll typically receive a decision by mail within a few weeks. The board can:

  • Lower your assessment
  • Keep your assessment the same
  • Raise your assessment (rare)

If you disagree with the decision, you have the right to appeal further to the Allegheny County Board of Viewers and then to the Court of Common Pleas.

What to Expect at the Hearing

The hearing is relatively informal compared to a court proceeding:

  • It usually lasts 10-15 minutes
  • You'll sit at a table with the hearing officer
  • You present your evidence and explain your position
  • The hearing officer may ask questions

Tips for a Successful Appeal

  • Be prepared: Organize your evidence clearly
  • Be specific: Focus on comparable properties, not general market trends
  • Be respectful: The hearing officer is there to be fair
  • Be concise: Stick to the facts about your property

Common Questions

How long does the process take?

From filing to decision typically takes 2-3 months, depending on the board's schedule.

What does it cost to file?

Filing an appeal with BPAAR is free. You only pay if you hire a lawyer or professional representative.

Can I appeal every year?

Yes, you can file an appeal every year if you believe your assessment is still too high.

What if I lose?

You can appeal the decision to the Board of Viewers and then to the Court of Common Pleas. However, most cases are resolved at the BPAAR level.

Ready to Get Started?

The first step is checking if your assessment appears high. Use our free tool to get an instant estimate.

Check your property assessment now

Learn More